By
Andy Semotiuk

Skilled Worker Evaluations: You Pass. No Wait, You Fail

February 9, 2015

US and Canadian Immigration Lawyer Andy Semotiuk: An interesting piece from Adrian Humphreys that looks at the problem of deciding which credentials will help potential immigrants get into Canada as a skilled worker:

Canada’s way of assessing potential immigrants under the Federal Skilled Worker program is so vague, the same applicant presenting the same paperwork could score either a high-flying pass or a dismal failing grade depending on interpretation, the Federal Court of Canada says.

The new assessment process for potential “economic-class” immigrants was found lacking in what is thought to be the first court challenge it has faced.

A financial analyst from Pakistan applying last year for permanent residence status in Canada as a federal skilled worker was given a score of five points, out of a potential 25, in the education category of her assessment.

It was argued in court that different assessments of the same credentials could have scored her 19 or even 23 points.

Federal Court Justice Cecily Strickland found all three scores could have been seen as correct or “reasonable.”

It is disturbing to think that the destiny of a person is hostage to such wide swings in interpretation of criteria. The government should seek to take the uncertainty out of the process. What is needed is a centralized decision maker on these credentials, and an accepted list of approved educational institutions.

An example understandable to Canadians would be that universities like McGill, University of Toronto and the University of British Columbia would be recognized as top tier institutions, and the graduate would be given an appropriate score. Graduates from other reputable institutions with shorter diploma programs – for example George Brown or Sheridan – might be accepted, but would be subject to some further degree of evaluation. On the other hand, Bob and Mary’s School for Movie Actors, even if it had a provincial licence, would require strict scrutiny and would be given a lower score still.

An alternative to this would be to use the US model of private sector evaluations. In that instance, all foreign credentials would be vetted by approved private evaluators, who would then submit their reports to the applicant to be included in their submission. If the government then sought to deny the application, it could attack the evaluator’s report. This would give the applicant a chance to reply, rather than deny them entry outright.

Whatever the case, it’s obvious from Humphreys’ piece that the evaluation process needs improvement.

Andy Semotiuk is a Canadian and US immigration lawyer with immigration law firm Pace Immigration. You can learn more about Andy at My Work Visa.

Share This Post
Email
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Trending Posts
Read More Insights
Events
By
Pace Law
Pace Law Firm is always looking to expand our business and elevate it to the next level. On Thursday November 24th, Pace Law Firm attended the Canadian Mortgage Summit (CMS) to hear from the industry’s top mortgage brokers, lenders and solution providers.
Firm News
By
Pace Law
We are proud to announce that Pace Law has become a multi-service firm and is launching a new website to accommodate our growth in different areas of law!
Events
By
Pace Law
The National Day for Truth and Reconciliation takes place on September 30th for the second consecutive year. Each year, September 30th marks both Orange Shirt Day and National Day for Truth and Reconciliation.
Real Estate Law
By
Pace Law
In key Canadian cities, the housing inventory may reach a crisis stage, according to a recent analysis from RE/MAX Canada. The analysis confirms that governments must take quick action to address the critically low supply of available homes.
Personal Injury
By
Pace Law
As the winter months get closer, it is critical to plan ahead and take precautions as needed to reduce the likelihood of mishaps. Nearly 30% of all motor vehicle incidents, according to recent RCMP data, happened on slick, snowy, or icy roadways.
Real Estate Law
By
Pace Law
Two weeks after the provincial administration submitted Bill 109, the More Homes for Everyone Act, 2022, on March 30, 2022, it obtained royal assent on April 14. The last step needed for a legislative measure to become law is royal assent.

Get in Touch

Call us now or fill out the form to discuss your case with an experienced legal professional.

Our Locations

Office Location

191 The West Mall, Suite 1100
Toronto, ON M9C 5K8
Phone: 1-877-236-3060
Fax: 416-236-1809

Office Location

191 The West Mall, Suite 1100
Toronto, ON M9C 5K8
Phone: 1-877-236-3060
Fax: 416-236-1809

Scroll to Top